Consumer Optimism Colliding with Record Debt

December 07, 2024

Good Morning Everyone -

In today’s issue we’re diving into the current consumer outlook, record high credit card debt, and how businesses can prepare.

Topics Covered

  • Current Consumer Behavior (Optimism with a Twist)

  • Record High Credit Card Debt

  • Primary Impacts on Businesses

  • How Businesses Can Adapt

Optimism with a Twist

Consumer spending drives the U.S. economy, contributing 68% to the country’s GDP in Q2 2024. As a result, the financial well-being of American consumers plays a crucial role in shaping overall economic performance.

A recent McKinsey report highlights a rise in consumer optimism, particularly among younger generations. Millennials and Gen Z are notably more optimistic about their financial futures compared to Gen X and Baby Boomers.

This optimism often translates to higher spending in the present. Consumers with greater confidence are more likely to spend on non-essential items while taking on more debt and saving less.

Despite the rise in optimism, concerns about inflation persist. The McKinsey report reveals that many consumers are still adjusting to elevated prices, even as the inflation rate has declined from 3.4% in 2023 to 2.6% in 2024. Although inflation is slowing, prices remain high compared to prior years, leaving consumers with a challenging adjustment period.

A significant trend is the rising tendency for consumers to "trade down" by purchasing smaller portions or opting for lower-quality versions of the same product. They’re prioritizing value, focusing on discounts, sales, and promotions to make their money stretch further.

For businesses, these trends emphasize the importance of offering value options to meet the needs of consumers who are cautious about spending—even as their overall outlook becomes more optimistic.

Record High Credit Card Debt

On the flip side, record-breaking levels of credit card debt are a growing concern.

Here are a few key statistics about American credit card debt:

  • Americans now owe a record $1.14 trillion on their credit cards, a 4.8% increase year over year.

  • Half of American credit cardholders carry a balance from month to month.

  • The average credit card balance is $6,239.

To put this into perspective, I plugged the average balance of $6,239 into a minimum payment calculator. If someone only makes the minimum payment, it would take nearly 25 years to pay off the debt. Over that time, they would pay almost $9,000 in interest—on top of the original balance.

This is particularly alarming because credit card debt is one of the most expensive types of debt a consumer can have. With average APR rates around 24%, it’s easy for people to fall into a debt spiral that becomes nearly impossible to escape.

As a result, credit card debt puts a strain on both current and future spending. The more debt consumers take on now, the more of their future income will be tied up in repayments. This leaves less discretionary income for spending with businesses in the future.

Consumers point to inflation and rising interest rates as the main drivers of their growing debt burden.

Primary Impacts on Businesses

So although optimism remains high, consumers are still closely watching their budgets. They’re hunting for strong deals and promotions to stretch their dollars further.

At the same time, rising credit card debt means a growing portion of consumers’ income will go toward paying off that debt, leaving less money for discretionary spending.

Here’s what businesses can expect to see in the future:

  1. Increased Demand for Discount Retailers: As debt burdens grow, discount retailers like Walmart and Dollar General are likely to see more traffic. Additionally, consumers may shift toward budget or off-brand versions of essential items.

  2. Growth in Secondhand Marketplaces: Platforms like eBay and Poshmark are expected to gain popularity as consumers turn to thrift or secondhand goods to save money.

  3. Boost for Debt-Related Services: Industries like debt consolidation, credit counseling, and personal finance education are likely to see increased demand as more consumers seek help managing their finances.

How Businesses Can Adapt

  1. Add Pricing Tiers to Your Offerings: Introduce tiered pricing options—low, medium, and high—to appeal to a wider range of customers and budgets.

  2. Offer Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL): Price-sensitive customers will appreciate businesses offering BNPL services like Affirm or Klarna. These services can make products more accessible without requiring consumers to rely on high-interest credit cards.

  3. Prepare for Higher Delinquency Rates: Businesses that offer financing or rely on customer credit (e.g., furniture or electronics retailers) should anticipate higher rates of missed payments. Banks may also tighten lending criteria, making it harder for consumers and businesses to access credit.

See you in the next one!

Oleg

Sources: